The Taylors & Company 1873 Comanchero 20-inch Octagon Lever Rifle is a full-size, classic-style lever-action built with traditional lines and period details. It features a 20-inch octagonal barrel, color case-hardened receiver, checkered straight walnut fixed stock, a buckskin lever wrap, an elk butt stock cover, and a raised gold-bead front sight. This rifle delivers authentic Old West looks with modern reliability.
| Manufacturer | Taylors & Company |
|---|---|
| Model | 1873 Comanchero |
| Material | Steel barrel and receiver, walnut stock (per manufacturer specs) |
| Compatibility | .357 Magnum / .38 Special (per manufacturer specs) |
| Finish | Color case-hardened receiver, blued barrel |
| Weight | Approximately 7.5 lbs (per manufacturer specs) |
| Condition | New |
Key Features
- 20-inch Octagonal Barrel — The octagon profile adds weight forward for steadier off-hand shooting and keeps the look true to the 1870s. It also helps dissipate heat during longer range sessions.
- Color Case-Hardened Receiver — This finish isn’t just for show. It provides a durable, mottled surface that resists wear and gives each rifle a unique pattern. Per Taylors & Company, the hardening process also strengthens the steel.
- Checkered Straight Walnut Stock — The checkering gives you a secure grip even with sweaty hands, and the straight grip suits traditionalists. The walnut is kiln-dried to prevent warping over time.
- Buckskin Lever Wrap and Elk Butt Stock Cover — These leather add-ons reduce lever slap on your knuckles and cushion the shoulder. They also give the rifle a seasoned, trail-ready appearance right out of the box.
- Raised Gold-Bead Front Sight — The gold bead catches light for quick target acquisition, and the raised blade works well with the semi-buckhorn rear. It’s a period-correct setup that still performs in low light.
Who It’s For
This rifle fits shooters who appreciate the 1873 Winchester lineage but want a ready-to-shoot replica without hunting down aftermarket parts. It’s ideal for Cowboy Action Shooting, plinking, or as a ranch gun for varmints. New gun owners who want their first lever gun will find the .357 Mag / .38 Special chambering mild on recoil and affordable to feed. Families looking for a shared range gun will appreciate the smooth action and easy-to-load magazine tube.
Pros and Cons
Pros: Authentic period details (color case-hardening, octagon barrel, leather wrap). Smooth action right from the factory. Shoots both .357 Mag and .38 Special for versatility. Walnut stock is checkered for a positive grip.
Cons: The 20-inch barrel makes it heavier than a carbine version — about 7.5 lbs — which some shooters may find tiring for all-day carry. The gold-bead front sight can be fragile if the rifle is dropped.
Comparison vs. Competitors
| Feature | Taylors & Company 1873 Comanchero | Uberti 1873 Sporting Rifle | Henry Big Boy Steel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barrel Length | 20 inches (octagon) | 20 inches (octagon) | 20 inches (round) |
| Receiver Finish | Color case-hardened | Color case-hardened | Blued steel |
| Stock | Checkered walnut | Smooth walnut | Walnut (checkered on some models) |
| Leather Accents | Buckskin lever wrap + elk butt cover | None | None |
| Caliber | .357 Mag / .38 Special | .357 Mag / .38 Special | .357 Mag / .38 Special |
| Price | $2,144.93 | ~$1,800 | ~$1,200 |
FAQ
What caliber does the Taylors & Company 1873 Comanchero use?
It chambers .357 Magnum and .38 Special. You can shoot both through the same rifle — .38 Special is lighter for plinking and .357 Mag gives more power for hunting.
Is the 1873 Comanchero ready for Cowboy Action Shooting out of the box?
Yes. The action is tuned smooth from the factory, and the 20-inch barrel meets most CAS rules. The leather lever wrap and elk butt cover are already installed, so you don’t need to add them.
Does this rifle come with a manual or warranty?
Yes, it includes a user manual and a limited warranty from Taylors & Company. Always read the manual before first use.
Can I mount a scope on this rifle?
The 1873 Comanchero has iron sights only — no scope mounts. It’s designed for traditionalists who prefer open sights. If you want optics, consider a different model with a drilled/tapped receiver.
How many rounds does the magazine hold?
The tubular magazine holds 10 rounds of .38 Special or 9 rounds of .357 Magnum (per manufacturer specs).
Ready to Order?
✔ Nationwide delivery (all 50 states)
✔ Ships 1-2 business days
✔ 30-day returns
✔ Secure checkout
Browse more lever-action rifles in our Lever Action Rifles section, or check out Cowboy Action Shooting gear and Hunting Rifles.
Last updated: April 2026
Reviews
There are no reviews yet.